![]() |
National Horseshoe Pitchers Association Publicity |
| # | Ringer% | Winner | R / SP | Loser | Year |
| 1. | 100.0% | Guy Zimmerman | 44 / 44 | Henry Pargal | 1948 |
| 2. | 100.0% | Elmer Hohl | 30 / 30 | Wes Kuchcinski | 1968 |
| 3. | 98.00% | Carl Steinfeldt | 49 / 50 | Wellington Taylor | 1964 |
| 4. | 97.73% | Don Titcomb | 43 / 44 | Marines Tamboer | 1960 |
| 5. | 97.62% | Ted Allen | 41 / 42 | Ralph Dykes | 1952 |
| 97.62% | Kevin Cone | 41 / 42 | Jim Hoyt | 1986 | |
| 97.62% | Walter Ray Williams Jr. | 41 / 42 | Jim Hoyt | 1986 | |
| 8. | 97.50% | Walter Ray Williams Jr. | 39 / 40 | Lowell Davis | 1988 |
| 97.50% | Alan Francis | 39 / 40 | Joe Schultz | 1990 | |
| 10. | 97.37% | Kevin Cone | 37 / 38 | Jesse Gonzales | 1991 |
| 11. | 97.22% | Walter Ray Williams Jr. | 35 / 36 | Elwyn Cooper | 1989 |
| 12. | 97.06% | Fernando Isais | 33 / 34 | Bruce Walters | 1947 |
| 13. | 96.88% | Casey Jones | 31 / 32 | A. J. Byrnes | 1947 |
| 96.88% | Lowell Gray | 31 / 32 | Bill Hill | 1951 | |
| 96.88% | Ralph Maddox | 31 / 32 | Nelson Vogel | 1964 | |
| 96.88% | Elmer Hohl | 31 / 32 | Elmer Harrison | 1973 | |
| 17. | 96.74% | Ted Allen | 89 / 92 | Cletus Chapelle | 1955 |
| 18. | 96.67% | Jim Knisley | 29 / 30 | Jesse Gonzales | 1986 |
| 19. | 96.43% | Mark Seibold | 27 / 28 | Gordon Meece | 1983 |
| 96.43% | Carl Steinveldt | 27 / 28 | Alvin Perry | 1987 | |
| 21, | 96.20% | Don Titcomb | 52 / 54 | John Elkins | 1958 |
| 22. | 96.15% | Mark Seibold | 50 / 52 | Harold Darnold | 1977 |
| 96.15% | Mark Seibold | 25 / 26 | Art Tyson | 1986 | |
| 24. | 95.83% | Jim Knisley | 46 / 48 | Mark Seibold | 1974 |
| 95.83% | Al Zagroga | 46 / 48 | Ansil Copeland | 1976 | |
| 95.83% | Carl Steinfeldt | 23 / 24 | Gary Roberts | 1982 | |
| 27. | 95.71% | Glen Henton | 67 / 70 | Floyd Fowler | 1964 |
| 95.71% | Walter Ray Williams Jr. | 67 / 70 | Dave Hughes | 1979 | |
| 29. | 95.65% | Don Titcomb | 44 / 46 | Harry Morse | 1959 |
| 95.65% | Walter Ray Williams Jr. | 44 / 46 | Phil Fleshman | 1991 | |
| 95.65% | Cliff Baker | 44 / 46 | Jim Knisley | 1991 | |
| 32. | 95.59% | Fernando Isais | 65 / 68 | Marines Tamboer | 1948 |
| 95.59% | Ted Allen | 65 / 68 | Louis Dean | 1955 | |
| 34. | 95.38% | Paul Focht | 124 / 130 | Marvin Craig | 1965 |
| 35. | 95.35% | Curt Day | 82 / 86 | Clair Bruce | 1969 |
| 36. | 95.31% | Ray Martin | 61 / 64 | Ron Simmons | 1969 |
| 37. | 95.24% | Ted Allen | 40 / 42 | Stan Manker | 1955 |
| 95.24% | Ted Allen | 40 / 42 | Harry Russell | 1955 | |
| 95.24% | Don Titcomb | 40 / 42 | Harold Wolfe | 1956 | |
| 95.24% | Glen Henton | 40 / 42 | Jim Johnson | 1965 | |
| 95.24% | Elmer Hohl | 40 / 42 | Bob May | 1979 | |
| 95.24% | Ralph Maddox | 40 / 42 | Karl Van Sant | 1982 | |
| 95.42% | Walter Ray Williams Jr. | 40 / 42 | Rogers Norwood | 1985 | |
| 44. | 95.16% | Elmer Hohl | 59 / 62 | Bill Holland | 1975 |
| 45. | 95.00% | Ted Allen | 95 / 100 | Stan DeLeary | 1947 |
| 95.00% | Curt Day | 76 / 80 | Al Zadroga | 1976 | |
| 95.00% | Mark Seibold | 57 / 60 | Floyd Toole | 1972 | |
| 95.00% | Ted Allen | 38 / 40 | Ron Cherrier | 1959 | |
| 95.00% | Al Zadroga | 38 / 40 | Mike Pateneaude | 1978 | |
| 50. | 94.90% | Glen Henton | 93 / 98 | Marvin Craig | 1964 |
| 51. | 94.83% | Clyde Martz | 93 / 98 | Ansil Copeland | 1970 |